Bone up before you buy: The ABCS of picking a Medigap policy

Bone up before you buy: The ABCS of picking a Medigap policy

By Christopher J. Gearon, Kiplinger’s Retirement Report

People enrolling in traditional Medicare should buy a supplemental insurance policy to cover the substantial gaps left by deductibles and co-payments, according to consumer advocates. But choosing a private Medigap plan can be daunting.

That’s what Joyce Katen discovered when she turned 65 in May.

“I got so confused,” says Katen, a clothing manufacturing consultant in New York City. She turned to the Medicare Rights Center (, a consumer group that helped her choose a policy among numerous offerings.

Like others approaching age 65, Katen first needed to decide how she’d protect herself against Medicare’s large coverage gaps. Most beneficiaries have two options. They can go with a private Medicare Advantage plan, which covers all Medicare benefits, provides drug coverage and limits out-of-pocket costs. Or they can opt for traditional Medicare and buy a separate Medigap policy and a Part D prescription-drug plan.

For Katen, that decision was easy. Advantage plans restrict your selection of providers, and Katen says she wants to be able to use any doctor she chooses, as traditional Medicare allows.

Then came the hard part for Katen: choosing a supplemental insurance policy. Medigap policies are sold by private insurers in 10 standardized benefit designs, named A through N. With some exceptions, coverage and price generally increase as you move up the alphabet.

Plans C and F are held by a majority of the 9 million Medigap beneficiaries. Both pay the deductible for Part A, which covers hospital costs, and for Part B, which covers outpatient costs. The deductible for Part A will be $1,260 for each benefit period in 2015, and the annual Part B deductible will be $147. (Plans E, H, I and J are no longer sold, but if you hold one, you can continue to keep it in most cases.)

To figure out which policy is best for you, consider your “health status, family medical history and risk tolerance,” says Casey Schwarz, policy and client services counsel for the Medicare Rights Center. Healthier beneficiaries who rarely need medical care may be best suited for high-deductible plans.

Plans K and L are high-deductible policies that have lower premiums but impose higher out-of-pocket costs. Plan F also offers a high-deductible version.

But new beneficiaries should not choose a plan based solely on their health today. As long as you buy a Medigap policy within six months of enrolling in Part B, an insurer cannot reject you or charge you more because of medical issues. If you become ill and want to switch to a plan with better coverage, an insurer can boost the cost or turn you down.

Katen decided to go with the fully-loaded Plan F. Katen, who is healthy, said she would rather pay more for comprehensive coverage and not worry about footing the bill if she gets sick.

“I can’t imagine not having the coverage,” Katen says. She pays UnitedHealthcare, which sells policies under the AARP name, a monthly premium of $261, in addition to the monthly $104.90 Part B premium she pays to Medicare.


Depending on the plans offered in your area, Plan N could be a middle ground for many healthy beneficiaries.

“Plan N provides very good coverage and is more affordable than Plan F,” says Ross Blair, senior vice president of, a division of online broker eHealth Inc. Plan N provides much of the same coverage as Plan F, but it doesn’t cover the $147 Part B deductible. It also charges a $20 co-payment for doctor visits and a $50 co-payment for emergency room visits that don’t result in hospital admissions.

In New York City, UnitedHealthcare offers a Part N plan for $178 a month, compared with Katen’s $261 premium for Plan F. Katen could still come out ahead with Plan N if she had two emergency room visits and 40 visits to the doctor.

Once you choose your plan category, it usually makes sense to go with the cheapest plan. Under federal law, all plans offered under the same letter must offer the same benefits. Prices for the same policy can vary widely, however. For example, annual Plan F premiums range from $1,752 to $3,768 in Rockville, Md., and from $2,472 to $6,552 in Miami.

Besides checking the initial premium, ask the insurer which of the three pricing methods it uses for the plan you’re considering. Attained-age pricing bases the premium on your age when you buy the policy, with rates rising as you grow older. Premiums can also increase because of inflation.

With issue-age pricing, the premium is based on the age at which you buy the policy (the younger you buy, the less expensive), and it will not change as you age, except for inflation. Community-rated policies charge the same price to everyone regardless of age, and your annual premium can only increase for inflation.

“We would encourage going with a community-rated plan, with an issue-age plan being the next best thing,” Blair says. He compares attained-age policies to variable-rate mortgages, which start off at a low price but can escalate considerably.

To understand how your costs may change over time, ask for a three- to five-year rate history for each policy you’re considering. Also ask for quotes as if you were age 70, 75 and 80. Some insurers will offer discounts — for nonsmokers, for women and for those who hold several policies with the company, such as homeowners and auto insurance.

While companies in most states can conduct medical underwriting if you apply for a plan after the initial six months are over, there are some exceptions. You can buy Medigap coverage without underwriting if you’re in a Medicare Advantage plan and you move out of its service area, or if your insurer stops selling the Medigap plan you currently have.

Another exception is if your retiree health coverage from a former employer ends. And some states, such as New York, prohibit underwriting after the six-month period.

To compare policies in your area, visit To get additional help, get in touch with your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program at You’ll find rules in your state by visiting the Web site of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners ( Note that Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin have their own standardized benefits.